Skip to main content

New Monday Feature: Discuss amongst yourselves

Which is the greater work of Art: Michelangelo's Pietà or the movie Fight Club?

Comments

Anonymous said…
A better question would be:

Is it better to wait to post something? Or is it better to post something crappy and hope that people do all your dirty work for you?

Bastard.
Dave said…
Next week's discussion question:

Can we all agree that Jorge is the biggest douche to ever post on this site?
Beth said…
Next week's answer: Yes.
Anonymous said…
Science bitches think alike...
Next week's answer is a resounding "Oui!"
Anonymous said…
Science bitches need Right Guard!
Jorge +10!
Jay said…
Remember that douche without the bag is just a shower.

Also, since I made it through The Agony and The Exctasy, I'd have to side with Fight Club, purely for the penguin scene.
Dave said…
I think it depends on how you define art; what separates Literature from a novel or The Theatre from a play. If you define art as something that changes your world view, or at least opens you to new ideas, then for me Fight Club wins out in this regard. When I saw the Pieta, I was astounded, but I pretty immediately returned to thinking about how my feet hurt and that if I didn’t eat something soon I’d murder someone. Fight Club opened me up to new ideas: can I improve myself through self destruction? am I, in fact, owned by my possessions? can I really make napalm with orange juice and gasoline? did my Dad have sex with Edward Norton’s mom thirty someodd years ago?
Anonymous said…
Your dad did have sex with her. In DA TUB!

Seriously, why would you call Art something that changes your world view? I always looked at art as a form of expression. A glimpse into someone else's perspective.

How then, do you separate literature from a novel?

I don't know.

I suppose, too, that we each have those types of art that we'd rather not see. Things that would send us out to poke our eyes with hot sticks, just for relief.

Maybe that is art. We suffer for it...

Popular posts from this blog

Discuss Amongst Yourselves - January 30th, 2006

In case you don’t read my comments (and if not, you’re nuts cause that’s where all the good stuff is), Courtney has just declared herself movie illiterate. So, if you had to recommend five essential movies that everyone should see, what would they be? Let me stress: only five. For those of you with break-the-rules tendencies (like--I dunno--just picking a name out of the air... Jorge ?), your comment gets chucked out. Give’r.

A complex phrase, in which the various parts are enchained

“Barry,” my cousin Mike said, “I think it’s time.” It was clear that my brother didn’t feel the same way, but he only shrugged, which Mike took as agreement. “Dave,” he said, giving the words as much gravity as he could muster, “Go get the dictionary.” I was nine years old, and a tag-along. I’d walked in on my brother telling a story about how—during school that morning—a girl he knew got her period in the middle of French class. And I laughed like the dickens. And then they called me on it. After I’d lugged the dictionary down from the spare room, Mike told me to look up the word period and read out the definition. “The end of a cycle, a series of events, or a single action?” “Keep going,” he said. “The full pause with which a sentence closes?” “Not that.” “An interval of geologic—“ “Gimme that!” He yanked the book towards him, read down the page, and pointed me towards the definition he’d found. Menstruation: the monthly discharge of blood from the uterus of nonpregnant women from pu...